A dinner with Pierre Miodownick of Netofa Winery, the most prolific of the kosher winemaker’s Noble Family

|

Created by:

1987 Chateau Les Forges Meuersault and PierreOn a warm Sunday night in January, GG and I were driving towards the home of Pierre Miodownick, to taste through the new Netofa wines and to enjoy an exciting dinner with Pierre, his lovely wife, and Yair Teboulle Netofa’s CEO. The evening started by setting our stuff in one of Pierre’s bedrooms, as we were staying overnight in their lovely home. After that, we joined Pierre and Yair for a tasting of each and every new wine that is available from Netofa, along with some that are not yet available and a few oldies as well. On top of that, as we got closer to dinner we enjoyed two wines that Pierre made from France, but ones that were created some 24 years apart from each! But we are jumping ahead of the story, so let’s start at the tasting.

photo 1When you enter the home of Mr. Miodownick, you cannot help but be in awe of the achievements that this man has single handily created in the last 32 years. He started his life’s work, in 1982, along with a man named Lionel Gallula (hence the M&G on his older vins negociants bottles) by going to wineries and making kosher wines inside of non-kosher wineries, mostly in the Languedoc region to start. Then in 1986, they approached Rothschild, and a few other French wineries mostly in the area of Bordeaux and the Loire Valley. Fast forward two years, in 1988, Royal realized they needed to expand their wine portfolio to include things other than their syrup-based wines, and their then-fledgling Herzog Winery. So, they reached out to Pierre and they soon joined forces. In my opinion, this was the single most important action Royal has taken in the past 20 years, a genius move that has allowed Royal to become the powerhouse that it is today. Pierre was the visionary, he was the one that realized that if he wanted to expand his kosher winery reach to more European wine regions than just Bordeaux and Burgundy, he would have been hard-pressed to do it all on his own. But with the strength, long arm, and pocketbook of Royal behind him, Pierre would be able to expand the wine regions where kosher wine exists today – like Italy, Portugal, Spain, and other regions in France.

IMG_0612From the outside, being a flying winemaker may look glorious and impressive, but it is a seriously hard job. Pierre is more often on the road than he is at home, but he tries to be home for most weekends. In the end, to me, he is part of the noble family of kosher winemakers, those that have been there from the start, the forefathers, if you may. They are; Pierre, Israel Flam, Shimshon Welner, and Peter Stern, who have all left an indelible impression on the kosher wine world for 25 or more years. Israel Flam was the first UC Davis trained winemaker in Israel and the winemaker of Carmel’s famous 1976 and 1979 Cabernet Sauvignon, Special Reserve, and is now involved in his children’s eponymous winery. Shimshon Welner is a man we have spoken about a few times in the past, here. Peter Stern was the winemaking genius, early on, behind Yarden Winery and Herzog Winery, before Victor Schoenfeld and Joe Hurliman took over respectively and is again being used by Royal and Carmel.

Pierre and his Netofa winesStill, of the four, Pierre may not have been the first, but he has been the most prolific of the group by a long stretch, over these past 32 years. To me, he is the head of the noble kosher winemaker family, and he is the Godfather of the noble family of all things kosher wine! It is his unique ability to happily build quietly without fanfare or accolades, though he deserves them. Rather he is a quiet, honest, hard-working man that has worked to get to where he is today. He has made more wine than almost any other kosher winemaker in the world! That is no small feat. Did he do each and every wine by his old hands, in the old days of 1982 – yes! Now, he has teams that help him, but so do other head winemakers. So, in the end, to me, he has the largest reach in the kosher wine world than any other person that I know of, which makes it so very impressive.

This content is for members only. Please Login  or Subscribe Here to continue reading!

Like This:

, , , , , , , , , ,
  1. Steven B Avatar

    So considering the fact that the 2013 Domaine Netofa Rose is 18.33 at Gotham I assume it goes without saying that it qualifies for your QPR designation

    1. winemusings Avatar

      AAH! I missed that – will ad thanks Steven!

  2. Elliot Lowy Avatar

    This sounds awesome. Now u know what to bring me next time 🙂

    Elie Lowy

    Louis Newman & Company P 212-719-2626 F 212-764-4329 http://www.louisnewman.com

    1. winemusings Avatar

      Will do my man!! LOL!

  3. […] Read the original post: A dinner with Pierre Miodownick of Netofa Winery, the most prolific … […]

  4. Steven B Avatar

    Is the Port available in the US? I haven’t seen it anywhere

    1. winemusings Avatar

      Both ports are unfortunately not sold here, best chance to get them is in Israel

  5. […] and the Weiss boys have clear leanings to the Rhone Varietals. I think the two of them, along with Netofa Winery. are the kosher manifestation of the Rhone Riders. Who else produces Grenache wines (Capcanes but […]

  6. frberlin Avatar

    Dear Winemusings – I recently enjoyed many a bottle of Capcanes Peraj petita at my seders and was stunned when one of my guests asked a question that had never crossed my mind: How logistically-speaking can one produce Kosher wine in Spain and Portugal? I since have read up on M. Miodownick and learned about all the fine work that he does. And yet, the question remains. Where do you find enough shomer shabbat Jews in Spain and Portugal to produce the wine – from vine to bottle as halacha dictates? I’ve been searching everywhere for an answer and was hoping that you might be able to enlighten me. Does M. Miodownick import observant Jews to make the wine? It must cost a fortune to do so, which leads me to wonder how it could be financially feasible for M. Miodownick and the winery (especially considering that the bottle I mentioned is quite good for its category and priced below $20). I eagerly await your response! best wishes – Adam

    1. winemusings Avatar

      Hello Adam,

      Thanks for the question! Please understand that oversight is required from crush till bottling, as you have said, and I have posted here. However, once the wine is in barrel or tank (depending on the type of wine) the oversight needed is not daily as much as weekly. That said, at crush they do import people to help with the process. However, after that the number of hands needed goes down and the local Rabbi(s) in Portugal and Spain take over. The local Rabbis work under and follow the rules of the overseeing auspice – AKA OU/OK etc.

      Yes, there are Rabbis in Portugal and they make their own local wines there as well, though not imported here any longer. In Spain there are many Jewish communities and they also make their own wines. Actually it was the local Jewish community of Barcelona that asked Capçanes if they could produce a kosher wine. This demanded the installation of new equipment allowing the winemakers to identify, isolate and vinify under controlled (not mevushal) conditions and small parcels with high quality fruit. Till then, Capcanes was on the verge of failing under the weight of its co-op system and with the help of the Jewish community it started created top line wines that have marveled us all!

  7. […] and Roussanne. These varietals are gaining traction in the kosher wine world, with great help from Netofa Wines, Vignobles David Winery, Reacanati Winery, Hajdu/Brob Wines, and Shirah […]

  8. […] interested in creating well-rounded and all around enjoyable wines – like Tzora, Recanati, Netofa, Yatir, Castel, Dalton, Flam, Four Gates, and many […]

  9. […] Yarden, Tabor, Teperberg, Recanati, and Lueria. Along with rose wines that are beautiful from Netofa, Lueria, Recanati, Agur, Dalton, Flam, and […]

  10. […] few weeks ago, I spent Shabbos with some friends, GG and Mendel from Israel and New York respectively, at Benyo’s house, home of the Four Gates […]

  11. […] balanced, controlled, and shockingly still has enough acid to keep going. Of course a wine like the 2011 Chateau Moulin Riche is an entirely different beast! That is a wine that is so French, it is insane. The wine is ripped, […]

  12. […] 2011 Chateau Moulin Riche, Saint Julein (QPR) – Score: A- to A This is a wine made by the same producer and with the same care as the famed Chateau Leoville Poyferre! The wine may be called a younger sibling or smaller sibling of the Leoville Poyferre Grand Vin, but it is not true in any way! I have now tasted this wine three times, in the short time period of a month, and this wine is ripped and muscled with deep and rich mineral notes that blew my mind along with acid and fruit that makes for a wine that will clearly be around for at least another 10 years.
This wine is a blend of 57% Cabernet Sauvignon, 33% Merlot, and 10% Petite Verdot. The PV addition adds great depth to the blend and builds the wine’s muscled earthy structure.
The nose on this black colored wine is lovely and rich with barnyard notes (interesting for such a young wine), graphite, along with fresh black fruit, lovely red fruit, raspberry, and dark cherry that comes together with perfumed sweet herb. The mouth on this crazy rich and layered full bodied wine, comes at you with layers of crazy mouth drying tannin, rich blackberry, cassis, rich minerality, charcoal, all integrated into the wine’s rich fruit structure making for a wine that can handle anything you throw at it. The finish is rich and long with crazy mineral and fruit, leather, coffee, and roasted herb. BRAVO!!!! […]

  13. […] example of a winery that has purposely and consciously taken the road of over ripe fruit. 8.    Netofa Winery (the 2013 and 2014 wines will blow your socks off) – not listed here because I will post […]

  14. […] about his wines but also mindful of the man who brought him fame in the kosher wine world – Pierre Miodownick. Of course, he has received world wide acclaim for his non kosher wines, which is well deserved, […]

  15. […] the kosher wine drinking world, could have ever been able to do that – without the one of the Godfathers of kosher wine; Pierre Miodownick. I will not repeat the history of M&G and their merging with Royal Wines. If you have not yet […]

  16. […] have previously posted about our tasting and dinner last year with Pierre Miodownick and the Netofa Winery. They are two entities that are deeply intertwined with each other essentially Netofa is Pierre. […]

  17. […] in the early 1980s, before Pierre started working for them or selling to them, Royal decided to make a set of moves that would cement them in the kosher wine industry as the […]

  18. […] port like wines. This is the second time I have tasted this yet unreleased wine and it is still very much inline with what we had last time, repeated here for clarity. This classical sweet wine Portuguese style wine uses the classic […]

  19. […] I have yet to truly find the joy of the Pavillon in comparison to the Moulin Riche, again IMHO. The Moulin Riche was made in 2011, 2013, and 2015. Finally, there is the Chateau Le Crock, a wine that they have been making kosher […]

  20. […] but this wine is a no brainer, no matter the cost if you like sweet port like wines. This wine is very much inline with what we had last time, repeated here for clarity. This classical sweet wine Portuguese style wine uses the classic […]

  21. […] I could not drink from France were lovely in 2015, though, it was also related to the fact that Pierre Miodownick, was the winemaker for those wines, more on that […]

  22. […] the best and most shocking wines (in a great way of course) of the event. The two new wines from Pierre Miodownick (who has started making new wines in France all on his own), the first ever 1er Grand Cru Classe […]

  23. […] have written before about what Pierre Miodownick has done for kosher wine and about Netofa Winery. The interesting fact beyond his epic work in creating kosher French wines, for over 30 years now, […]

  24. […] but this wine is a no brainer, no matter the cost if you like sweet port-like wines. This wine is very much in line with what we had last time, repeated here for clarity. This classical sweet wine Portuguese style wine uses the classic […]

  25. […] 2018 Chateau Cantenac Brown, Margaux is the second kosher release by Pierre Miodownick (who also is the head winemaker of Netofa Wines) from this esteemed winery in Margaux. Pierre is […]

  26. […] we have not had one since 2004 and sadly, that wine is long dead. However, we did have a lovely Meursault, in 2014, with Pierre Miodownick, and that wine was really fun! There were Pinot Noir Burgundies from 2019, along with a few Bourdeaux wines as well, from both […]

  27. […] Vigneau. The latest vintage of Sauternes from the main label was 2018. However, in 2022 and 2023, Pierre Miodownick and Mercier made two dry wines and one second label Sauternes. Both of these dry wines took forever […]

Leave a Reply to A dinner with Pierre Miodownick of Netofa Winery, the most prolific … | Which Wine Is SweetCancel reply

Discover more from Kosher Wine Database

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading